REPRESENTATION
Ask the union to act.
The vaccination-policy resolution calls for legal action, an investigation and collection of members’ grievances.
Read the actual resolutionTHE STORY BEHIND MAILER 6 · 23 OCTOBER 2026
Member resolutions. Money.
Fair treatment.
New to this story? Start here. Three events help explain why Members First is calling for clearer rules and public accountability.
Understand it from the beginningAbout 7 minutes · Plain-language guide to Mailer 6, pages 2–3
One guiding question:
How do members hold their union accountable?
FIRST, THE BASICS
The vaccination resolution and the donation proposal belong to the same period. They ask for different actions.
REPRESENTATION
The vaccination-policy resolution calls for legal action, an investigation and collection of members’ grievances.
Read the actual resolutionFINANCIAL ASSISTANCE
Mailer 6 describes proposed donations of $100,000 to each of three organizations, subject to a majority pilot-group vote.
Read the mailer’s accountThe vaccination PDF contains no donation amounts and no mention of AFDCA. It is not the financial-assistance resolution.
THE NAME THE MAILER DOES NOT SPELL OUT
Atlas Flight Deck
Crewmembers Association
A 2022 lawsuit complaint identifies AFDCA and describes its members as opposing Atlas’s COVID-19 vaccination mandate. It names AFDCA as one of the three proposed donation recipients.
This identification comes from the complaint, not from Mailer 6. A complaint records the plaintiffs’ allegations; it is not a court finding.
Read paragraphs 271–276 of the complaint ↗01 / THE MEMBER PROPOSALS
Mailer 6 says members advanced resolutions at the March 30 General Membership Meeting about meetings, vaccination policy and financial assistance.
Subject to a majority pilot-group vote.
That condition is stated in Mailer 6. This briefing does not have a result from that vote or a payment record.
Mailer 6 supplies the amounts and voting condition. Paragraph 271 of the 2022 complaint names the three organizations. The original financial-assistance resolution is not included in the records linked here.
WHAT HAPPENED NEXT, ACCORDING TO THE MAILER
Mailer 6 says Local counsel William Wilder rejected the resolutions’ binding effect and the Executive Board adopted his position.
Members ask for a course of action.
Mailer 6 describes a required majority pilot-group vote.
A transfer would need its own financial record. None is shown here.


WHERE JOHN AND JESSE FIT
Our published advocacy record carries John’s account that he and Jesse attended the March 2022 meeting to advocate against the company’s vaccination policy. John supplied the vaccination resolution used in Briefing 9.
That does not identify who introduced the separate donation motion. The vaccination PDF does not name its author or proposer, or record its adoption.
Open the existing vaccination briefing ↗02 / THE CAMPAIGN DESCRIPTION
The dispute described in Mailer 6 is about where the proposed $300,000 would go—and the condition attached to it.
BOTH DESCRIPTIONS BELOW ARE SUMMARIZED FROM MAILER 6. THE ORIGINAL 2023 CAMPAIGN PUBLICATION IS NOT REPRODUCED HERE.
THE PROPOSAL, AS MAILER 6 DESCRIBES IT
AFDCA would receive $100,000 of the proposed $300,000 total.
Majority pilot-group vote required.THE EARLIER CAMPAIGN CLAIM, AS MAILER 6 DESCRIBES IT
Mailer 6 says a Paulsen–Knox publication characterized the proposal as an attempt to direct the full $300,000 to AFDCA.
Members First disputes that characterization.The total stays $300,000. The proposed recipient allocation changes. Dividing the money among three organizations is different from assigning it all to one. A proposal dependent on a vote is also different from a completed payment.
To assess the competing descriptions, readers need the original donation resolution and the complete 2023 campaign publication. Neither is among the source documents linked here.
03 / DISCIPLINE AND CONSISTENCY
Mailer 6 says Sean McHugh brought charges against John Corcoran and Jesse Johansen alleging dual unionism and interference.
The authors explicitly dispute those allegations. The charge documents and a decision resolving them are not included here.
The mailer asks whether comparable accusations have received comparable treatment. That is a question for the records to establish.
This briefing does not establish guilt, exoneration or the current procedural outcome.
Mailer 6 says an earlier Paulsen–Knox publication accused Pete Tanner of dual unionism over APU. Its authors say they are unaware of comparable charges against him and intend to examine the different treatment.
Not knowing of charges is not proof that none existed. The original publications, charge records and any procedural decisions would be needed to make a supported comparison.
WHAT COMES NEXT?
Page 3 says Members First is preparing a documented examination of bargaining, grievances, the resolutions, Board responses and disciplinary proceedings, including a response to Wilder’s memorandum.
It explains the supplied material and identifies the gaps. It is not the complete examination promised in Mailer 6.
OPEN. READ. DECIDE.
Start with the source for each statement. A campaign account, a proposed resolution and a legal complaint do different jobs.
Pages 2–3 provide the campaign’s historical account, disputed interpretations and promise of a fuller examination.
Three pages calling for union action, investigation and collection of grievances. No donation provision or recorded adoption.
A separate one-page proposal for monthly general membership meetings. The supplied copy does not record a vote or implementation.
Paragraphs 271–276 identify AFDCA and the three proposed recipients. These are allegations and descriptions in a complaint, not adjudicated findings. Hosted externally on Scribd.
Understand the proposal.
Check the description.
Follow the process.